CBSE Class 9 · NCERT Ganita Manjari, Part II · Chapter 9

Chapter 9: Propositions and their Converses

If X then Y, and if Y then X: when a statement and its converse are true, and one counterexample to break a claim. This chapter is broken into 12 skills; each has an animated lesson and practice questions that never repeat.

What you learn in Chapter 9

  1. Skill 1

    What is a proposition?

    A statement that is either true or false. Questions, commands and opinions are not; a false statement still is.

  2. Skill 2

    If X then Y: hypothesis and conclusion

    'If X then Y', 'X implies Y', 'Y when X' and 'every X is Y' all say the same thing. Find the if-part.

  3. Skill 3

    Writing the converse

    The converse of 'if X then Y' is 'if Y then X': swap the two parts, do not add a 'not'.

  4. Skill 4

    Is the statement true? Is the converse?

    All four cases happen: both true, only the statement, only the converse, or neither. Both true means X and Y imply each other.

  5. Skill 5

    Counterexamples

    One case where the if-part holds and the then-part fails is enough to show a claim false. Many examples never prove it true.

  6. Skill 6

    Propositions about numbers and equations

    x = y implies x² = y², but not the other way: 3² = (−3)². x = y and x³ = y³ imply each other; so do x = y and a + x = a + y.

  7. Skill 7

    Divisibility statements and their converses

    Divisible by 24 implies divisible by 4 and 6, but 12 breaks the converse. Divisible by 5 and 12 does give divisible by 60.

  8. Skill 8

    Perfect squares and the number of factors

    Factor-partner pairs: n has an odd number of factors exactly when it is a perfect square. p² has 3 factors, pq has 4.

  9. Skill 9

    Prime formulas and famous counterexamples

    4n² + 1, n² + n + 11, 4n + 3 and 2ⁿ − 1 all fail somewhere. Euler broke Fermat's claim about 2^(2ⁿ) + 1.

  10. Skill 10

    Converses in geometry

    Isosceles triangles and equal angles, parallel lines and corresponding angles, squares and equal angles, area and congruence.

  11. Skill 11

    The converse of the Baudhāyana–Pythagoras theorem

    If a² + b² = c², the triangle is right-angled, with the right angle opposite c. Proof: build a right triangle and use SSS.

  12. Skill 12

    Propositions in the exercises

    Exercise Set 9.1: frame converses, judge both, and break the false ones: parallel lines, squares, divisibility, factors, primes, sticks.

Free lesson · What is a proposition?

Sorting sentences: proposition or not?

A proposition is a statement that is either true or false. 'If two sides of a triangle are equal, then the angles opposite them are equal' is a proposition, and it is true. '7 is an even number' is also a proposition: a false one.

Questions ('Is 51 prime?'), commands ('Close the door'), wishes and opinions ('Cricket is the best game') are not propositions, because they cannot be true or false.

Angles of a triangle add to 180°true → proposition
Start

'The angles of a triangle add up to 180°.' This can be checked and it is true: a proposition.

Remember: Proposition = a statement that is true or false. Questions, commands and opinions are not.

Sample questions with solutions

In the portal every question is generated fresh, so you never see the same one twice, and a wrong answer tells you which mistake you made.

Question 1 · Is the statement true? Is the converse?

"Lines l and m are parallel" and "the corresponding angles made by a transversal of l and m are equal" imply each other. What does that mean?

  1. A. Both statements are false
  2. B. Only 'if X then Y' is true
  3. C. Both the statement and its converse are true
  4. D. Each is the opposite of the other
Show answer and solution

Answer: Both the statement and its converse are true

  • 'Imply each other' means X implies Y and Y implies X.
  • Statement true: the corresponding angles axiom for parallel lines.
  • Converse true: equal corresponding angles force the lines to be parallel.
Question 2 · Divisibility statements and their converses

Statement: "If n is divisible by 18, then n is divisible by both 2 and 9." Converse: "If n is divisible by both 2 and 9, then n is divisible by 18." Which is right?

  1. A. Statement true, converse false
  2. B. Statement false, converse true
  3. C. Statement and converse both true
  4. D. Statement and converse both false
Show answer and solution

Answer: Statement and converse both true

  • Statement true: 18 is a multiple of 2 and of 9.
  • Converse true: a number divisible by 2 and 9 is divisible by their LCM, 18 = 18.
Question 3 · Propositions in the exercises

Counterexample hunt: 'If n is a prime number, then 2ⁿ − 1 is prime.' Find the smallest prime n that breaks it.

Show answer and solution

Answer: 11

  • n = 2, 3, 5, 7 give 3, 7, 31, 127: all prime.
  • n = 11 gives 2047 = 23 × 89. (n = 4 gives 15, but 4 is not prime.)

Common mistakes in this chapter

  • Judged a statement true or false wrongly

    True means true in every case. Look for one case that breaks it; if you find one, it is false.

  • Added 'not' instead of swapping

    'If not X then not Y' is not the converse. The converse only swaps X and Y; no 'not' appears.

  • That example agrees with the claim

    A counterexample must make the if-part true and the then-part false. An example where both hold supports the claim.

  • The if-part is not true for that example

    If the condition X fails, the case says nothing about 'if X then Y'. Pick a case where X holds and Y fails.

  • Mixed up the if-part and the then-part

    In 'Y when X' or 'X implies Y' the condition is X. Ask: what is given, and what follows from it?

Where is this used?

  • Wet roads and tanker trucks

    'If it rains, the road is wet' is true, but a wet road does not prove it rained. Mixing up a statement with its converse is the most common mistake in everyday arguments.

  • Advertisements and fine print

    'All our toppers used this guide' does not mean 'if you use this guide, you will top'. Spotting the converse hiding in an advert saves money.

  • Forwarded messages and rumours

    'It worked for my cousin' is one example, not a proof. One clear counterexample, though, is enough to show a claim like 'this always cures a cold' is false.

  • Rules at home and at school

    'If you finish homework, you can play' does not say what happens if you don't. Reading the if-part and the then-part exactly is how you understand any rule.

Find your gap in Chapter 9

Log in with your phone number: lessons for all 12 skills, endless practice, a chapter test and a report that shows exactly what to fix.

Start with your phone number